Click on a Menu below to View

We happily do special orders for cupcakes, cakes, cookie platters, gift baskets and more!


We take pride in our ingredient selection and take great care to ensure that we continue to be a nut and peanut-free facility. Recently our demand for chocolate and butterscotch chips has increased greatly, even exceeding our own expectations. To prevent us from ever running out of your favorite menu items, we have carefully chosen to switch our supplier to Barry-Callebaut Chocolate. If you have any questions, feel free to send us an email at or stop by the bakery. We are looking forward to an exciting holiday season filled with our favorite cupcakes, cookies, pies, bars, and more.


What is your ordering policy?

The Little Daisy Bake Shop is currently experiencing a high volume of custom cake requests for weekend days. We love celebrating your special milestones, birthdays, anniversaries, corporate events, wedding and more! We are committed to creating freshly-baked, made-to-order, custom decorated cakes, and our team takes pride in knowing that everything we make is baked with care, using fresh ingredients and are always peanut and nut-free.

Since we receive a large volume of custom orders every day, we request that all orders be placed as follows:

  • *All Thanksgiving orders must be placed by Tuesday 11/13
  • *All Holiday orders must be placed by Monday 12/17*
  • Custom Cakes: 2 weeks advance notice
  • Sugar Cookie Favors: 2 weeks advance notice

Cupcakes, cookies, brownies, whoopie pies, Daisy Dips, etc. are available at The Little Daisy every day. For orders of a dozen or more of one item we ask the following lead times.
  • Cupcakes - 12-24 hours advance notice
  • Cookies (chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, etc) - 12-24 hours advance notice
  • Platters (cookies, bars, breakfast) - 24 hours advance notice
  • Breads (seasonal: banana, pumpkin, lemon etc.) - 24 hours advance notice
  • Daisy Dips - 3 days advance notice.

When circumstances allow, we will do our best to accommodate all order requests. It is best to stop by the shop during regular business hours, or give us to call. Please note The Little Daisy Bake Shop may impose an earlier cutoff date and time for holiday orders.

We understand your frustration. Our goal is to honor every single order that comes into the door or is made through the phone. We are looking into hiring additional help to facilitate all custom orders. In the meantime, we ask for a minimum of a two-week notice for all custom cake and sugar cookie orders.

How do I place an order?

We invite you to come into The Little Daisy Bake Shop and talk to us in person, or you can call 973-707-2157. If we are not able to pick up the phone, it means we are baking and helping customers. Please leave a message and we will return your call as soon as possible.

We are so thankful for our customers, and we are humbled by the increasing requests for custom cakes and hand-decorated cookies! Our philosophy is to bake fresh with the best ingredients. We do not freeze cakes and we take a lot of time and care with each cake design. With this philosophy in mind, we have a limit for what is possible for us to create for any given weekend. We wish we could accommodate unlimited order requests but we have made the conscious choice not to compromise our quality for quantity. We take pride in our creations and our customers expect our best work. Please note that customers are ordering cakes weeks and sometimes months in advance.

We can almost always accommodate cupcake and breakfast item requests.